Not Born YesterdayOnline safety, plain & simple

HomeSpot a scam › How to Spot an Online Scam: A Plain-English Guide for Seniors

Learn the signs

How to Spot an Online Scam: A Plain-English Guide for Seniors

Scams are designed to rush you, not outsmart you. Learn the 7 warning signs that give away almost every online scam — in plain English, no tech skills needed.

Plain-English, no tech skills needed Last reviewed: June 2026

Here is the most important thing to know about scams: they are not designed to outsmart you. They are designed to rush you.

A scammer's whole job is to get you feeling something strong — fear, excitement, worry about a family member — and then to keep you moving fast, before you have a chance to stop and think. That is the trick. Not clever technology. Not some skill you're missing. Just speed and pressure.

Which means you already have everything you need to protect yourself. You don't have to be "good with computers." You just have to know the warning signs and give yourself permission to slow down.

This guide walks you through the seven signs that give away almost every scam. Learn these, and you'll spot the trick coming a mile away.

The one question that stops most scams

Before we get to the warning signs, here's a single habit that stops the large majority of scams on its own:

When someone contacts you, verify them yourself — using a number or website you find on your own.

A scammer will always give you a way to "check" — a phone number to call back, a link to click, a person to ask for. That contact information leads straight back to them. So don't use it.

If "your bank" calls, hang up and call the number on the back of your card. If "Medicare" emails, close it and go to medicare.gov yourself. If "the government" says there's a problem, look up that agency's real number and call it.

Real organizations will never mind you doing this. Scammers can't survive it.

The 7 warning signs of a scam

1. They create a sense of urgency

"Act now." "Your account will be closed in one hour." "You must pay today or you'll be arrested."

Urgency is the number-one tool of every scammer. They want you scared and rushing, because a rushing person doesn't stop to check. Real companies and real government agencies give you time. Pressure to act right now is one of the clearest signs you're being scammed.

2. They ask for an unusual way to pay

This one is almost a guarantee. Scammers ask to be paid in ways that are hard to trace and impossible to get back:

  • Gift cards — they'll tell you to buy cards and read off the numbers on the back
  • Wire transfers — sent through your bank or a service like Western Union
  • Cryptocurrency — often by feeding cash into a "Bitcoin ATM"
  • Cash by mail or courier — sometimes even gold

No real business, bank, or government agency will ever ask you to pay a bill, a fine, or a fee with a gift card or a Bitcoin machine. If that comes up, you are talking to a scammer. Full stop.

3. They tell you to keep it secret

"Don't tell anyone." "Don't discuss this with your family." "This has to stay between us."

Scammers know that the moment you mention it to your spouse, your daughter, or a friend, someone calmer will see right through it. So they work hard to keep you isolated and on the phone. Any request for secrecy is a glaring red flag. A trustworthy person wants you to check with the people you trust.

4. They contacted you out of the blue

Did you get a call, text, email, or message you weren't expecting? Treat it with caution. Most scams begin with contact you didn't ask for — a surprise text about a package, a pop-up warning on your screen, a friend request from a stranger, a call about a problem you didn't know you had.

This doesn't mean every unexpected message is a scam. It means an unexpected message is the moment to put your guard up, not down.

5. They want you to "move your money to keep it safe"

This is one of the most damaging scams of all, and it deserves its own warning. Someone calls — pretending to be your bank, a government agency, even a "fraud investigator" — and tells you your money is in danger. The only way to protect it, they say, is to move it: into a "safe account," into cryptocurrency, or by handing cash to a courier.

Here is the truth the FTC repeats again and again: nobody legitimate will ever tell you to move or transfer your money to protect it. That request, by itself, means it's a scam. The "safe account" is theirs.

6. It's too good to be true

A prize you didn't enter. A lottery from another country. An investment with "guaranteed" high returns and no risk. A sweetheart you met online who needs a little help. A refund larger than you expected.

When an offer is far better than anything you'd normally see, that's not luck — that's bait. Real prizes don't require you to pay a fee to collect them. Real investments don't promise guaranteed returns.

7. They ask for passwords, codes, or control of your computer

No legitimate company will ask for your password. None will ask you to read back the security code they just texted you — that code is the key to your account, and handing it over lets a stranger walk right in. And no real "tech support" agent calls you out of the blue asking to take control of your computer to "fix a problem" you didn't report.

If anyone asks for a password, a verification code, or remote access to your device, stop immediately.

Where scams reach you

Scammers will use any door that's open:

  • Phone calls — still a favorite, because a live voice can ramp up the fear
  • Text messages — fake delivery notices, fake bank alerts, fake "recalls"
  • Email — fake invoices, fake security warnings, fake account problems
  • Pop-up warnings on your screen — usually pretending to be Microsoft or Apple
  • Social media — fake friends, fake romances, and fake "investment" tips, now one of the most common starting points

The door changes. The warning signs above stay the same.

The simple rule: Stop. Don't act. Verify.

If you remember nothing else, remember these three steps:

  1. Stop. Notice the rush, the fear, the pressure. That feeling is the warning.
  2. Don't act. Don't pay, don't click, don't move money, don't share a code — not yet.
  3. Verify. Hang up. Look up the real number yourself. Ask someone you trust. There is no problem so urgent that you can't take ten minutes to check.

Scammers lose the moment you slow down. That's the whole game.

Trust is yours to give

The deeper idea behind all of this — and the heart of Not Born Yesterday — is simple: you decide who earns your trust, on your terms, not theirs. Our 10 Laws turn that idea into ten plain-English rules you can lean on for any message, any caller, any website, so you never have to figure it out from scratch in the heat of the moment.

If you'd like the full framework — all 10 Laws, plus step-by-step walkthroughs for your phone, email, and accounts — that's exactly what the guide is for.

Next: see these warning signs in action in the most common scams targeting seniors right now — or, if something has already happened, here's exactly what to do if you've been scammed.